The Beachcomber's History
The Beachcomber, located on West Lake Road at Conesus Lake, NY, began as a small grocery store called Peg's Point, built by B.C. Mehlenbacher in the early 1930s. After Prohibition ended in 1933, it became a restaurant and taproom.
In the 1950s, the property was remodeled and renamed The Beachcomber, gaining popularity as a lakeside resort and restaurant. Over the decades it changed ownership several times, with each group contributing to its unique character and traditions.
In 2005, Tom and Mary Alice May purchased the property and began extensive renovations and improvements. Today, The Beachcomber offers food, drinks, entertainment, dock access, beach activities, volleyball leagues, and overnight accommodations — all overlooking beautiful Conesus Lake.
Together with their family and staff, the Mays continue to carry on the tradition of making The Beachcomber a favorite gathering place in the Finger Lakes.