Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting The Beachcomber. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Our Soon to be Famous French Toast
Love, Love!! We've never had anything we have not loved from the dining menu or the Crab shack menu!
Dublin Lawyer
We dined at the beachcomber with our closest friends and family for our rehearsal dinner, this past August. My husband and I usually dine out by the water at he cabana bar, but for this special meal we ate inside. I was floored at how delicious the seafood entree was! Very creamy, very tasty! The service was above and beyond. She even made a special request to substitute the lobster because I prefer crab. Such a wonderful experience. I can't thank you enough for your hospitality! We will always be returning customers. *Mike and Nicole
12 oz. Ribeye
If you're looking for a dining experience second to none, this is your place! Chef May will have you re-evaluating your previous standards of fine cuisine, with every single bite (literally). The crab cake appetizer was visually mouth watering and tasted even better. My steak was juicy and perfectly seasoned, while still preserving the natural flavors of the prime cut ribeye. The true dessert is the wonderfully diverse upscale, blue collar, family and adult themed atmosphere. My wife and I like to stay the weekend in the clean, cozy rooms that overlook the indoor/outdoor bar, beach, boats, bandstand and beautiful lake! Thanks to the geniunely friendly staff and other local patrons, our stay is always beyond words. Thank you !!!!
Broiled Seafood Platter
Hubby had ribeye steak....i had seafood platter. BOTH delicious....steak and seafood cooked perfect! We had our usual apps also: crab cakes and calamari.......we get these every time we visit. BEST crab cakes we've ever had! We have stayed here several times....since honey moon four years ago. This is our little gem! Will continue our tradition each year for the great food and great staff!( Btw...rooms are gorgeous and well maintained....) A MUST for anyone looking for a great time.
Burger
Great burger, you could tell it was hand formed in the kitchen and not just a frozen patty. Fries were decent also.
Fish Sandwich
My son doesnt like beer battered fish, so he tried this sandwich and loved it. Good sized sandwhich too. Crispy and delicious! Beachcombers is a cool place. Great views, laid back atmosphere, volleyball, pool table, darts. Also had a fire pit outside, which wasnt lit at the time. (I assume it's a weekend thing) But just an all around fun place to be. We will be back for sure!
Soft Pretel Sticks
Great app. They come with a little butter on them too but not drenched. They were great. Would definately order again.
Loaded Fries
BIG order of loaded fries! My wife and I shared them at the bar. Great snack to fill up on. Smothered with cheese and bacon. What more could you ask for?
Nachos Grande
Great food and awesome music!! People are super friendly. I can't wait to go back
Fried Clam Strips with French Fries
Love going here for the fried seafood baskets. So much fun watching the volleyball games. It's like hanging at a Florida beach bar/restaurant. Highly recommend for a fun night!
Burger
I had the burger without a bun, extra tomatoes, onions, lettuce and ketchup, it was delicious! I Love being able to come in off the boat and eat overlooking the lake!
Chef's Choice Sliders
I had this special one night it was the perfect balance of jalapeño heat and sweet. Three sliders came on a rectangular plate with a drizzled design on it. I thought it was a special because of the price. But, it was everything about the beachcomber that was special. Our favorite bartender make our drinks exactly how we like it. Can't say enough about how much we love das beachen comber
Haddock Fish Fry
outstanding! more than enough to eat Great atmosphere, really enjoyed the evening, had fun dancing on the grass to the band!
BBQ Plate
Love the bacon bbq burger with fries n onion rings which includes the ice cold beers with fabulous live evening entertainment around a magnificent lake atmosphere!! Heading there again this evening!!!
Crab Cake Dinner
Finally Crab Cakes that can compete with Maryland. Makes my wife very happy as she lived on the Eastern Shore of Maryland and I fell in love with them there as well.
Beachcomber Calamari
I've been to the Beachcomber only once, and though I thought it a little pricey the food was amazing. I look forward to going again sometime.
Deep Fried Pickle Spears
Absolutely DELICIOUS fried pickles! They are always a favorite of mine! Looking forward to coming back the week of July 4th!
Pulled Pork Sandwich
The meat is tender and the sauce is delicious. I have not had a 'bad' meal and we visit several times a week. Thank you Mary Alice
Burger
Love the burgers here!! Anything outside is good! Service is awesome! You have to stop on by & try it!!!
Philly Steak Hoagie
This Philly steak rocked! It really hit the spot. The toasted, crunchy bun was a nice addition to the classic steak, cheese, peppers and onions. Would definitely recommend.
Haddock Fish Fry
We love their fish fry. Good sized portion, cooked perfectly with a crisp coating and moist fish.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
All their food is amazing, it's hard to pick a favorite! Always a great environment, friendly staff, good times! I bring my family here for lunch when they're in town, and my friends and I come here to unwind after a week! It's a great spot and well ran company! Highly recommend!
Chicken Fingers
My daughter had these and she loved them, I tried one as well. Tasted great and done perfectly.
Chef May's Famous Seafood Chowder
Seafood chowder was delicious, full of flavor and served hot. We sat at the dockside bar which also has a pool table and darts. Cool place, a must see!
Littleneck Clams (10)
Great stop on Conesus lake! First time here and we loved it! Beach bar with a great view. Clams were delicious and fresh! Volleyball was being played at the time, which was fun to watch, and our bartender Tabitha was great! Friendly and attentive.
12 oz. Ribeye
This place is outstanding. So many people having fun and enjoying the constant party that seems to be the Beachcomber. The steak I had was done to perfection and the service was paced just right. Thank you for a wonderful evening.
Crab Stuffed Haddock
We always have a great experience! The food is delicious and the quantities are plentiful. Both my husband and I have leftovers. We really enjoyed the live music. (I actually went to the website to look up the name of the band). Sitting outside on a summer night makes you feel like you are on vacation. We can't wait to go back!
Dublin Lawyer
The most unbelievably amazing dish! We camp at Conesus Lake Campground and eat here at least 2-3 times a month and I'm always getting the Dublin Lawyer... The prices are amazing and the service from the servers to the bartenders is phenomenal!
Fish Sandwich
The fish sandwich is my favorite lunch menu. The fish is always fresh and delicious. Our home is Scottsdale, AZ and we vacation with family on Conesus lake every summer. Coming to the Beachcomber is one of the highlights of our trip!! See you 4th of July week!!!
Dublin Lawyer
This dish is fantastic. It's definitely my go to dish. The whiskey cream sauce is to die for. The seasoned veggies and garlic mashed are second to none. Great with a risling or two as well. The atmosphere and views are amazing and it's always a great time! Great for families and for date night. We frequent the beachcomber for these reasons!
Deep Fried Pickle Spears
Deep fried pickles??? Amazing. Poutine... yummy! Great apps to share then a delicious dinner. Fun atmosphere on the water... love it!
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Boy we always love boating or riding the bike out from west Henrietta for a lake get a way here! Great food!awsome entertainment and the view! They had the place beautifully fixed up for Memorial Weekend. Great Fun thank you!! Bob
Maryland Crab Cakes
Best crab cakes around! Lots of lump crab meat with a delicious remoulade sauce!
Chef May's Famous Seafood Chowder
The Beachcomber is an idyllic place on conesus lake - you can enjoy scenic views and an excellent menu . Your choices range from casual to fine dining and your guaranteed excellent service and a friendly warm atmosphere !
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
September:
Announced soon
August:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill - Columbus, GA
July:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet - Buffalo, NY
June:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar - Cape Cod, MA
May:
Karen, This Little Pig - Amherst, NY
April:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria - Atlanta, GA